
Moral Realism · Theology
The Kingdom of God Is Within You
by Tolstoy · The Searcher of Conscience · Russian Realism, 1828-1910
Tolstoy argues that Christ's command of nonresistance exposes the violence sustaining church, state, war, property, and social obedience.
- Brutal
- ~9 hr read
- 4 chapter guides
- Public domain
Start reading · Read the Chapter III guide free
Before the text
Editor's Prelude
Christianity against Coercion
The command to love an enemy sounds simple until a state orders someone to kill him. Leo Tolstoy makes that clash the center of The Kingdom of God Is Within You. He asks how people who profess Christian love can accept armies, prisons, and punishments that depend on hurting other people.
Tolstoy was a celebrated novelist when he began writing about his religious beliefs. Russian censors suppressed his earlier statement of faith, but copies circulated and replies reached him from abroad. Christian pacifists, who rejected violence even in war, showed him that others had long taught nonresistance. Critics tried to show why his beliefs could never govern ordinary life. He answers both from a society where landowners' comfort could depend on the suffering of hungry peasants.
This is a polemic: an argument meant to challenge beliefs and change conduct. Long quotations sit beside personal encounters and sharp attacks on familiar excuses. Its repetitions keep bringing public duty back to a person's conscience. Tolstoy's nonresistance means refusing to use violence against evil. His demand reaches everyone whose obedience helps other people use it.
The opening pages
Title and Epigraphs
"Ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free."
"Fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul; but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell."
"Ye have been bought with a price; be not ye the servants of men."
"THE KINGDOM OF GOD IS WITHIN YOU"
CHRISTIANITY NOT AS A MYSTIC RELIGION BUT AS A NEW THEORY OF LIFE
TRANSLATED FROM THE RUSSIAN OF
COUNT LEO TOLSTOY
BY
CONSTANCE GARNETT
NEW YORK THE CASSELL PUBLISHING CO. 31 East 17th St. (Union Square)
Copyright, 1894, by THE CASSELL PUBLISHING CO.
All rights reserved.
THE MERSHON COMPANY PRESS, RAHWAY, N. J.
Chapter I
"THE KINGDOM OF GOD IS WITHIN YOU."
CHAPTER I.
THE DOCTRINE OF NON-RESISTANCE TO EVIL BY FORCE HAS BEEN PROFESSED BY A MINORITY OF MEN FROM THE VERY FOUNDATION OF CHRISTIANITY.
Of the Book "What I Believe"—The Correspondence Evoked by it—Letters from Quakers—Garrison's Declaration—Adin Ballou, his Works, his Catechism—Helchitsky's "Net of Faith"—The Attitude of the World to Works Elucidating Christ's Teaching—Dymond's Book "On War"—Musser's "Non-resistance Asserted"—Attitude of the Government in 1818 to Men who Refused to Serve in the Army—Hostile Attitude of Governments Generally and of Liberals to Those who Refuse to Assist in Acts of State Violence, and their Conscious Efforts to Silence and Suppress these Manifestations of Christian Non-resistance.
Among the first responses called forth by my book were some letters from American Quakers. In these letters, expressing their sympathy with my views on the unlawfulness for a Christian of war and the use of force of any kind, the Quakers gave me details of their own so-called sect, which for more than two hundred years has actually professed the teaching of Christ on non-resistance to evil by force, and does not make use of weapons in self-defense. The Quakers sent me also their pamphlets, journals, and books, from which I learnt how they had, years ago, established beyond doubt the duty for a Christian of fulfilling the command of non-resistance to evil by force, and had exposed the error of the Church's teaching in allowing war and capital punishment.
In a whole series of arguments and texts showing that war—that is, the wounding and killing of men—is inconsistent with a religion founded on peace and good will toward men, the Quakers maintain and prove that nothing has contributed so much to the obscuring of Christian truth in the eyes of the heathen, and has hindered so much the diffusion of Christianity through the world, as the disregard of this command by men calling themselves Christians, and the permission of war and violence to Christians.
Chapter guides · 4
Chapter III
Churches Against Christ's Teaching
Tolstoy argues that churches protect their power by keeping people from understanding Christ's teaching.
A Teaching Grown Obscure
Tolstoy argues that only a minority has ever taken Christ's teaching in its plain sense, while for most people it has grown more and more obscure. Believers and unbelievers alike assume they already understand it; the Church hides its meaning from believers, he says, and Science from unbelievers. At first the teaching offered no proof but its truth and asked people to keep moving toward perfection and the kingdom of God. But early followers soon claimed that miracles guaranteed their own reading, starting with the assembly in Acts that credited its decision to the Holy Ghost. Tolstoy follows that claim to Constantine's creed and to modern dogmas of infallibility.
Churches and Heresies
Tolstoy denies that Christ founded a Church. He quotes Catholic, Orthodox and Lutheran catechisms, each of which places only its own members inside the true Church. A church, he concludes, is a body of people claiming complete and sole possession of the truth, and heresy is the name it gives to any opinion that rejects part of its creed. Drawing on Gottfried Arnold's history of heresy, he argues that living efforts to understand Christ came from so-called heretics, and that churches as institutions stand for pride and violence against Christ's meekness and humility. Good churchmen such as Francis of Assisi were good in spite of the institution they served.
The Church at Work
Turning to the present, Tolstoy lists the rites the Russian Church teaches from birth to death and calls them idol-worship; faced with a choice between the Sermon on the Mount and the Creed, churchmen have chosen the Creed. In a monks' bookshop he recommends a Gospel for an old peasant's grandson, and a monk answers that it “will not do for him.” Churches everywhere are the same, he argues: cheap Gospels and contact with other faiths make their doctrines hard to believe, so they rely on force in Russia, on spectacle everywhere and, above all, on deceiving children. He ends by saying that if they paused even briefly, people would begin to understand Christ's teaching, so their work is to instill a false interpretation of it and prevent a true one.
Chapter VI
How Educated People Excuse War
Tolstoy examines three ways educated people talk about war and finds that none asks whether each person should take part.
Salt on a Bird's Tail
Tolstoy argues that educated people, rather than change their lives to match conscience, work to quiet conscience, and that their views of war show this most clearly. He sorts them into three groups, all of whom treat war as beyond the will of those who fight it and never ask, “How about me—ought I to take any part in it?” The first group, represented by the London Peace Congress and writers in the Revue des Revues, hopes that arbitration, treaties and disarmament will end war. Tolstoy compares this hope to catching a bird by putting salt on its tail: governments rest on their armies and will never give them up. They welcome peace talk, he says, because it distracts people from whether each of them should serve.
War as Tragedy
A second group sees war as horrible but fated. Guy de Maupassant describes recruits driven like sheep to slaughter, mocks Moltke's claim that war saves men from “the most hideous materialism,” and imagines soldiers turning their arms on governments, yet concludes that the day will never come. Edouard Rod pictures whole nations marching to a war they cannot stop. Tolstoy points out that both writers place the power in the hands of the people who make up the armies, yet treat the horror as life's tragedy instead of looking for a way out.
War as a Benefit
A third group, including Moltke, most military men and some educated civilians, calls war necessary and even good. The academicians Camille Doucet and Jules Claretie praise peace but accept fighting, and Émile Zola calls war “necessary and beneficial.” The writer de Vogüé appeals to Darwin and Joseph de Maistre to present violent struggle as both a natural and a divine law, and warns that the certainty of peace would corrupt humanity. Tolstoy condemns this group most strongly because it denies that good and evil exist, and he says such arguments only deaden conscience. Yet he ends with hope: it is in darkness that light begins to shine, and it is rising on his own age.
Chapter IX
Freedom Begins with Each Person
Tolstoy argues that freedom comes from each person living by the Christian view of life, and sees individual refusals as a growing threat to rulers' power.
Chapter XII — Part 4
The Ending Returns Responsibility
Tolstoy ends by asking people to acknowledge the truth they know, even when changing their lives is difficult.
Questions readers ask
- How long does it take to read The Kingdom of God Is Within You?
- About 9 hr in total.
- How difficult is The Kingdom of God Is Within You?
- Brutal. A long work of theology; about 9 hours of reading.
- Which translation is this?
- The Constance Garnett translation from the Russian, first published in 1894. The text follows The Kingdom of God Is Within You: Christianity Not as a Mystic Religion but as a New Theory of Life, translated by Constance Garnett (New York: The Cassell Publishing Co., 1894).
- Can I read The Kingdom of God Is Within You for free?
- The Kingdom of God Is Within You is part of Nexus Premium, so reading it needs an account and a Premium subscription. The opening above and two chapter guides on this page are free to read.
- How many chapter guides are there?
- 4 chapter guides, written by the Nexus editors. Two open in full here; the rest show their opening line.
About Tolstoy
Leo Tolstoy was a Russian novelist, moral thinker, and social critic whose major works brought family life, history, death, violence, faith, and moral awakening into vast narrative form. His later spiritual crisis reshaped his public life and gave his fiction an even sharper judgment on vanity and false living.
“What does a life become when it can no longer hide from truth?”
Tolstoy gives Nexus the widest moral canvas in fiction: private homes, public history, illness, war, faith, and the exact moment when a person sees life differently.
Source text: public domain. Chapter guides: original Nexus writing. The Kingdom of God Is Within You is part of The Nexus Archive, guided Quests through the great works.